Metallica's Reviews

S & M

(Average Rating: 8.46 out of 10)

Great idea

(Rated this album with 10 out of 10)
Reviewed by Nick from Grand Rapids, Michigan United States

This CD was really good! One of my favorites of Metallica. Unlike a lot of other bands they actually sound really good live. The orchestra adds a lot to it too. Now I will do a song breakdown
Disc 1
1.Ecstacy of Gold: Introduction to the album, not anything too great but worth the listen 7/10
2. Awesome song! One of my favorites, even if it is only instruments it is a great song! 10/10
3. Master of puppets: Good song, sounds really good with the orchestra. 9.5/10
4. Of wolf and Man: An alright song, glad they had it on the album but not my favorite. 8/10
5. The thing that should not be: Ok, not my favorite 7.5/10
6. Fuel: Cool song 8.5/10
7. The Memory Remains: Really good song, the orchestra added a lot and it sounds really good live.
8. No leaf clover: Another one of my favorites on the album. 9/10
9. Hero of the Day: A soft song but still good. 8/10
10. Devils Dance: An awesome song. 9/10
11. Bleeding Me: One of my favorites on the album. 10/10
Disc 2
1. Nothing Else Matters: Good song, a good first song for disc 2. 9/10
2. Until it sleeps: Cool, really well done song. 10/10
3. For whom the Bell tolls: Orchestra adds a lot to an already good song. 10/10
4. Human: Previously unreleased, a good song that sounds excellent live
5. Wherever I may Roam: Orchestra does a lot to the song, I like the live version a lot.
6. Outlaw Torn: Really good song, really long though. 9.5/10
7. Sad but True: Good song, excellently. 9/10
8. One: Another one of my favorites 10/10
9. Enter Sandman: I didn't really like the version on the black album, but the live version was great! 10/10
10. Battery: Very good and really energetic. 10/10

There is a couple of minor things that disapointed me like that they didn't have Sanitarium or Fade to Black. But that is surely no reason to not buy the CD. Buy it, definetley!

Buy this album on Amazon at $22.99